Home

The Chernobyl and Fukushima accidents are comparable

False
While these two accidents originated in nuclear power plants, they differ markedly in their consequences and the sequence of events that caused them.
Read more

Water vapor released by nuclear power plants worsens climate change

False
Nuclear power plants release water vapor, a powerful greenhouse gas, but it rapidly condenses into precipitation due to the limited ability of air to store it. These emissions therefore do not contribute to the increase in the greenhouse effect.
Read more

There is no safe radiation threshold.

Incomplete
The health effects associated with exposure to low doses of radioactivity remain controversial. The effects of low doses, if any, are so small that they have not yet been confirmed. By adopting the "linear no-threshold” dose-effects model, radiation protection organizations are making a deliberately conservative choice to protect populations.
Read more

It would have been preferable not to evacuate the people of Fukushima immediately

True
Research today questions the extent, suddenness, and duration of the evacuations around Fukushima, whose impact on the health of the populations concerned would ultimately be more severe than the effect of radioactive discharges if these people had remained at home or returned more quickly.
Read more

Uranium mining is responsible for the emergence of several armed conflicts in Africa

Biased
Studies tend to show that uranium mining alone is not a factor conducive to the emergence of conflicts. However, if uranium mining is associated with the presence of disadvantaged ethnic groups in the same territory, then the risk of armed conflict increases.
Read more

Japanese food products became dangerous after Fukushima

Misleading
The negative image around food produced in Japan has weighed heavily on the Japanese economy and on local producers who still struggle to make a living from their production, which nevertheless conforms with consumer standards.
Read more

The nuclear industry has learned nothing from Fukushima

False
The analysis and feedback from this accident, which we must not underestimate and which was preventable, made it possible to improve the level of safety of nuclear reactors, in Japan and worldwide, with the active and immediate participation of the global nuclear industry.
Read more

The cost of waste is never taken into account

False
In accordance with French law, the costs of dismantling and managing nuclear waste are included in the cost of nuclear energy, in the form of mandatory financial provisions established by the operator. These costs are also systematically incorporated into assessments when developing public policies.
Read more